Hermès wins Birkin Bags NFT trademark case

by Ana Lopez

After making waves in the art world, NFTs face major legal hurdles. A federal case adjudicated in Manhattan just tested NFTs and the limits of intellectual property rights, ultimately winning luxury brand Hermès $133,000 in damages from artist Mason Rothschild, who made and sold non-replaceable tokens of the brand’s iconic Birkin handbag .

According to the Wall Street Journal, this is one of the first cases to address the intersection of NFTs, IP law and the protection of free speech in the arts.

Hermès sued Rothschild for more than 100 images he called MetaBirkins. The NFTs depicted handbags with the same shape and style as the luxury accessories. Hermès claimed the images infringed on their trademark. Yet Rothschild’s attorneys argued at trial that the brand’s trademark rights didn’t apply because the NFTs were protected works of art intended to make a statement about conspicuous consumption.

The outcome of the case is likely to provide a boost to companies seeking to protect their intellectual property from being traded and sold on virtual marketplaces. If Rothschild had won, it could have led to significant legal disruptions, but the victory for Hermès means that existing intellectual property doctrine remains unchanged.

This is not the only lawsuit of its kind. Other companies, including Nike and Miramax, have filed lawsuits alleging that NFT creators have infringed on their trademarks and copyrights.

The emergence of NFTs has led to several new challenges for intellectual property law. Businesses need to keep pace with evolving technology or risk losing their legal battles. The outcome of this ruling is a reminder that existing IP laws still apply in the digital world and can be used to protect the rights of companies.

Related Posts